Poland’s claim for reparations
Ever since The Report on the Losses Sustained by Poland as a Result of German Aggression and Occupation during the Second World War, 1939-1945, was published on 1 September 2022, some questions have been repeatedly asked about Poland’s claim for reparations.
On this page, we provide answers to the main questions people have asked.
- Why is Poland asking for reparations for the Second World War?
- How much reparations does Poland want for the Second World War?
- What demands did the Polish government make to Germany?
- Who wrote the War Report and why?
- Why is the issue of reparations for Poland being raised now?
- Wasn’t the issue of reparations for Poland closed?
- Didn’t Poland get reparations by getting German land?
- Is reparations for Poland in the media?
Why is Poland asking for reparations for the Second World War?
War reparations are compensation payments made after a war by one side to the other. They are intended to cover damage or injury inflicted during a war.
International law is clear in that a party that causes harm must redress an injured party for that harm. The 1907 Hague Convention – signed by Germany – states that a belligerent party is responsible for all acts committed by its armed forces.
Further, Poland and Germany have never signed a peace treaty to settle the issue of the Second World War.
Therefore, Poland is claiming reparations for:
- the damage and loss caused by the Germans during the Second World War, and
- the continuing negative effects of that damage in numerous areas that continue until today.
In this post, we look at the wide range of areas for which Poland is seeking reparations as, to date, no compensation has been paid. Please click here to find out more about why Poland is asking for reparations.
How much reparations does Poland want for the Second World War?
The War Report calculated the amount of reparations the German state must pay to Poland for the Second World War at PLN 6 trillion, 220 billion and 609 million as of 31 December 2021. That is approximately $1.532 trillion or €1.352 trillion.
That figure is a conservative figure that was calculated based on Polish “Core Lands”, i.e. the area that was part of Poland both before and after the Second World War.
Since the War Report was published on 1 September 2022, the models used to calculate the amount of reparations have not been criticised or challenged.
What demands did the Polish government make to Germany?
On 3 October 2022, Polish Foreign Minister Zbigniew Rau signed a diplomatic note that was then delivered to the German government. That diplomatic note set out 9 demands for Germany to pay war reparations.
To find out more about the Polish State’s 9 demands, please click here.
Who wrote the Polish War Report about Second World War losses and why?
The Parliamentary Group for the Estimation of the Amount of Compensation due to Poland from Germany for Damage Caused during the Second World War, established on 29 September 2017, was responsible for overseeing the creation of the War Report
The Parliamentary Group, made up of MPs, worked with a team of experts in various scientific disciplines including history, demographics, economics, and property valuation. Those experts drafted the chapters of the War Report.
To find out more about the War Report and why it was drafted, please click here.
Why is the issue of reparations for Poland being raised now?
There are numerous reasons why the Polish state is now making claims for reparations. In this post, we briefly look at 8 reasons that provide historical, legal, social, and scientific reasons that explain why:
- the War Report project started in 2017 and was published in 2022, and
- now is the time to re-open the discussion about reparations for the Second World War.
Please click here to find out more about why the issue of Polish reparations is being raised now.
Wasn’t the issue of reparations for Poland closed?
No. On 20 April 2023, a Council of Ministers’ Resolution was published that made it categorically clear that Poland has never renounced its claim for reparations. Poland’s claim for reparations remains open and has never been regulated after the war. However, even though the Resolution is clear, many use false arguments to claim that Poland renounced its claims to reparations, e.g. the Yalta and Potsdam Agreements, the “1953 waiver”, and the Two Plus Four Agreement.
In this post, we explain:
- what the Resolution says,
- why those commonly held arguments are incorrect,
- why the issue of Polish reparations remains open, and
- why, consequently, Poland has a valid claim to reparations.
Please click here to find out more about why the issue of Polish reparations is not closed.
Didn’t Poland get reparations by getting German land?
Poland did not receive German land as a form of reparations. This is a popular misconception.
The events that led up to Poland’s borders being redrawn after the Second World War are readily accessible online and in history books. Despite this, it is incorrectly believed that the German lands given to Poland were a form of post-WW2 reparations or that Poland’s claims for reparations might lead to the Polish-German border being redrawn.
Please click here to see why Poland’s borders were redrawn and the reasons for this.
Is reparations for Poland in the media?
It is! From the moment the War Report was published, numerous articles and stories have been written about Poland’s claim for reparations. In fact, the international media are writing more frequently about Poland’s claim for reparations as the issue is gaining popularity in international circles
Pages in this section
Why is Poland asking for reparations for the Second World War?
Poland is claiming war reparations from Germany because of uncompensated human and material losses suffered during WW2. This article explains why Poland is making a claim.
How much reparations does Poland want for the Second World War?
Poland is claiming PLN 6.2 trillion in reparations from the German state because of WW2. Here, we explain how the War Report arrived at this figure for reparations.
What were the Polish government’s 9 reparation demands sent to Germany?
On 3 October 2022, the Polish state sent a diplomatic note to Germany setting out 9 demands for Germany to pay Second World War reparations. Find out what those 9 demands were.
Who wrote the Polish War Report about Second World War losses and why?
Poland's War Report calling for reparations for the Second World War was published in September 2022. Find out why the War Report was published and who were the authors.
Why is the issue of reparations for Poland being raised now?
Why is the issue of reparations for Poland being raised now? The issue of reparations due from Germany to Poland still remains an open issue – even almost 80 years after the end of the Second World War. Due to communist rule, the turbulence of Poland’s democratic transformation, and the decades since, other issues […]
Wasn’t the issue of reparations for Poland closed?
Poland's claim for WW2 reparations remains open as Poland & Germany didn't sign a formal peace treaty. Find out why arguments suggesting otherwise are incorrect.
Was German land a form of Polish reparations?
Did Poland gain German land in the Potsdam Agreement as a form of reparations? Poland did not “gain” German lands as a form of reparations. The need to dispel the popular misconception that Poland “gained” lands is semantically important as “gaining” is widely understood as receiving a benefit. However, Poland did not receive a benefit. […]
Milestones and activities: Poland’s Campaign for Second World War Reparations
Track the milestones achieved and the activities that have taken place to communicate why Poland is claiming Second World War Reparations from Germany.
Reparations for Poland in the media
Poland's claim for WW2 reparations is being discussed in the media. Here, we link to the articles about Poland's reparations from international media outlets.